Are discount auto insurance companies trustworthy? (2026)

Discount auto insurance companies are trustworthy and can provide reliable coverage. To find the best policy, you'll want to compare quotes, customer service, financial ratings, and discount insurance reviews. You can save up to $100/mo by comparing rates from the top car insurance companies.

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide State Farm Allstate
AllstateState FarmNationwideLiberty MutualFarmers Insurance
Tonya Sisler

Insurance Content Team Lead

Tonya Sisler has been a technical insurance writer for over five years. She uses her extensive insurance and finance knowledge to write informative articles that answer readers' top questions. Her mission is to provide readers with timely, accurate information that allows them to determine their insurance needs and choose the best coverage. Tonya currently leads a team of 10 insurance copywrite...

Written by
Tonya Sisler
Jimmy McMillan

Licensed Insurance Agent

Jimmy McMillan is an entrepreneur and the founder of HeartLifeInsurance.com, an independent insurance brokerage. His company specializes in insurance for people with heart problems. He knows personally how difficult it is to secure health and life insurance after a heart attack. Jimmy is a licensed insurance agent from coast to coast who has been featured on ValientCEO and the podcast Modern Li...

Reviewed by
Jimmy McMillan

Updated December 2024

Are discount auto insurance companies trustworthy? The answer to this age-old question is a tough one to answer with a simple yes or no. Simply put, each auto insurance company is different.

are discount auto insurance companies trustworthy

One discount auto insurance company may be trustworthy while another is not. However, you don’t have to guess when trying to determine the best auto insurance companies. Compare quotes, coverage options, financial ratings, auto insurance discounts, and customer service to find a reputable insurer.

Start by entering your ZIP code into our FREE auto insurance comparison tool to compare cheap rates from trustworthy companies.

Things to Remember

  • Discount auto insurance companies can provide adequate, reliable coverage
  • Research any potential car insurance provider before purchasing a policy
  • Use a car insurance agent to help find a reputable insurance company

How to Know if Discount Auto Insurance Companies Are Trustworthy

There are various things you can do to ensure that the discount car insurance company you choose is reliable, including checking their customer service ratings and comparing quotes.

Research Car Insurance Providers

Before committing to any auto insurance provider, it’s crucial to thoroughly research the company, including examining reviews on limited insurance discounts, assessing customer service, and verifying their financial stability. It’s important to determine its legitimacy through unbiased reviews and ratings.

One of the fastest ways to do this is by checking their ratings on several different rating agencies websites. Agencies such as A.M. Best, J.D. Power and Associates, and Moody’s Investor’s Service rate auto insurance agencies big and small to determine which ones offer the best services and which ones you should avoid.

Typically, more expensive insurance companies rank higher, but discount insurers are also rated on these platforms. In fact, if the insurer you’re considering isn’t listed on such sites, it could be wise to avoid them entirely. This applies to verifying the legitimacy of insurance rates for less and exploring options for car insurance price matching.

You can also check with the Better Business Bureau. Obviously, a company with a failing BBB grade should be avoided; don’t take it for granted that a company with a good rating is foolproof.

Consumer rating platforms like Angie’s List can provide valuable insights into specific discount insurance agencies, although access often requires a membership fee. This applies to assessing the legitimacy and reading reviews about how to secure low car insurance rates.

The information will contain both positive and negative information regarding experiences that customers have had with the company you are looking to contract with.

Compare Quotes

Another way to make sure that you are getting an insurance policy from a trustworthy source is to get quotes from a wide variety of insurance companies.

Find free cheap auto insurance quotes as well as quotes from their pricier, name brand counterparts. Make sure that each quote is exactly the same in terms of the types of auto insurance coverage and auto insurance deductible. In addition, always ask the more expensive insurer if they’re willing to price match.

Read More: How to Evaluate Auto Insurance Quotes

Usually, they will bring the price of a more expensive policy in line with a discount auto insurance policy, allowing you to find discount auto insurance pricing while keeping your business with a reputable company.

In most cases, insurance companies won't directly price-match their policies with those of a competitor. However, many may be willing to lower their prices to gain a new customer.

Tracey L. Wells Licensed Insurance Agent & Agency Owner

There are various factors that affect auto insurance rates, such as driving history, credit score, age, and other factors, but you could influence those costs by comparing and offering price quotes from other companies. (Read More: How Credit Scores Affect Auto Insurance Rates)

Work Through an Insurance Agent

There are many trustworthy auto insurance companies that are largely unknown to the general public.

The main reason for this is that they control costs by choosing to refrain from large-scale advertising. Working through an insurance agent to find the best insurer at the best price is a great way to get quotes from otherwise invisible insurance companies. (Read More: How can I find auto insurance agents in my area?)

Free Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide State Farm Allstate

More About Whether Discount Auto Insurance Companies Are Credible

Thoroughly research any insurance company you are thinking about using in order to determine the level of customer satisfaction they offer, whether or not their pricing structure is competitive, and how easy their claims service is to use.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are discount auto insurance companies?

Discount auto insurance companies are insurers that provide reduced premium rates compared to conventional insurers. They accomplish this by offering discounts linked to factors like safe driving histories, vehicle safety features, bundled policies, and more. For those seeking a review of the cheapest auto insurance or reviews of discount auto insurance companies, understanding these factors is crucial.

Read More: How to Save Money by Bundling Insurance Policies

Are discount auto insurance companies trustworthy?

It’s essential to assess each insurance company independently. Many discount auto insurance companies can be relied upon, but thorough research is key. Factors such as financial stability, customer reviews, ratings, claims handling, and coverage options should be carefully reviewed before selecting. This applies to reviews of discount auto insurance groups, discount car insurance rates, and discount landlord insurance.

What are the advantages of choosing a discount auto insurance company?

  • Lower premiums: Discount auto insurance companies typically offer lower rates, allowing you to potentially save money on your car insurance.
  • Customizable coverage: Many discount insurers provide a range of coverage options, allowing you to tailor your policy to your specific needs.
  • Flexible payment options: These companies often offer flexible payment plans, making it easier for policyholders to manage their insurance expenses.
  • Online and digital services: Discount insurers often provide user-friendly online platforms and mobile apps, enabling convenient policy management, claims filing, and customer support.

What are the disadvantages of choosing a discount auto insurance company?

  • Limited coverage options: Some discount insurers may offer fewer coverage options compared to traditional insurance companies, limiting your choices.
  • Customer service concerns: As discount insurers may have fewer physical branch locations, customer service support may be primarily conducted online or over the phone, which may not suit everyone.
  • Potential coverage gaps: Low premiums may come with reduced coverage limits or exclusions, so it’s important to carefully review policy terms and conditions to understand what is covered and what is not.
  • Claims handling differences: It is essential to research and ensure that the discount insurance company has a good track record of prompt and fair claims handling.

How can I determine if a discount auto insurance company is trustworthy?

To assess the trustworthiness of a discount auto insurance company, consider the following steps:

  1. Research and reviews: Look for customer reviews and ratings to gauge the experiences of other policyholders.
  2. Licensing and regulation: Verify if the insurer is licensed and regulated to operate in your state. You can check with your state’s insurance department for this information.
  3. Financial strength: Review the financial stability and strength of the insurer by checking their ratings from reputable rating agencies like A.M. Best, Standard & Poor’s, or Moody’s.
  4. Claims handling: Research how the insurer handles claims and if they have a reliable and efficient claims process.
  5. Customer service: Consider the level of customer service provided by the insurer. Look for accessible communication channels and responsiveness to customer inquiries.

Who is the most trusted insurance company?

In terms of customer service ratings and size, State Farm and USAA are some of the most trusted auto insurance companies.

Who has the best customer service for auto insurance?

USAA is widely recognized for offering top-notch customer service within the auto insurance sector, varying based on individual needs for the best car insurance coverage. The cost to insure the cheapest Toyota depends on the model.

What insurance companies have the most complaints?

Of the top auto insurers, AAA and Allstate have the highest complaint index from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners.

Who is cheaper: Geico or Progressive?

Usually, you’ll find the cheapest rates with Geico, though Progressive has better average rates for high-rsik drivers.

Why is Geico so cheap?

Geico sells its insurance directly to consumers, cutting out the need for in-person agencies, and it also offers various discounts.

More FAQs

Get a FREE Quote in Minutes

Insurance rates change constantly — we help you stay ahead by making it easy to compare top options and save.

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide State Farm Allstate
NationwideAllstateFarmers InsuranceState Farm