Best Colorado Auto Insurance in 2024 (Top 10 Companies Ranked)

Top Pick Insurance in Colorado: Allstate

11,413 reviews

Compare Rates →

3.8

Company Facts

Full Coverage in Colorado

$166/mo

A.M. Best Rating

A+

Complaint Level

Low

Pros & Cons

• Multiple coverage options
• Various discounts
• Additional savings programs
• Low-mileage policy option

• Lower than average customer service ratings
• Higher than average auto insurance rates

» Allstate Auto Insurance Review

11,413 reviews

Compare Rates →

Best Safety Discounts in Colorado: Farmers

2,903 reviews

Compare Rates →

4.3

Company Facts

Full Coverage in Colorado

$163/mo

A.M. Best Rating

A

Complaint Level

Low

Pros & Cons

• Extensive coverage and discount options
• High customer service ratings
• Offers Signal, a usage-based insurance discount

• Not available in every state
• Rates are higher than average

» Farmers Auto Insurance Review

2,903 reviews

Compare Rates →

Best for Military in Colorado: USAA

6,435 reviews

Compare Rates →

4.7

Company Facts

Full Coverage in Colorado

$78/mo

A.M. Best Rating

A+

Complaint Level

Low

Pros & Cons

• Offers multiple products including financial services and banking
• High customer satisfaction and financial ratings
• Rates are lower than average
• Coverage is available in all 50 states
• Easy-to-use mobile app

• Coverage isn’t available to everyone
• DUIs drastically increase rates
• SafePilot isn’t available in every state
• Customer complaints are higher than competitors

» USAA Auto Insurance Review

6,435 reviews

Compare Rates →

The best Colorado auto insurance rates are offered by Allstate, Farmers, and USAA starting at $23 monthly. Allstate stands out for its excellent coverage options and customer service tailored to auto owners in Colorado. Compare quotes from providers to find the best deal for your needs.

Colorado auto insurance costs more than the national average due to factors that affect auto insurance rates like heavy traffic, higher car thefts, and winter weather.

Our Top 10 Company Picks: Best Colorado Auto Insurance

Company	Rank	Safe Driver Discount	A.M. Best	Best For	Jump to Pros/Cons
	#1	10%	A+	Customized Policies	Allstate
	#2	8%	A	Safety Discounts	Farmers
	#3	15%	A++	Military Savings	USAA
	#4	5%	A+	Loyalty Rewards	Progressive
	#5	12%	B	Local Agents	State Farm
	#6	7%	A	Claims Service	American Family
	#7	10%	A+	Exclusive Benefits	The Hartford
	#8	8%	A+	Accident Forgiveness	Nationwide
	#9	5%	A+	Dividend Payments	Amica Mutual
	#10	9%	A	24/7 Support	Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual, Geico, and State Farm offer some of the lowest rates in Colorado.

Find out more about car insurance in Colorado and how to get affordable coverage in Denver, CO. Get fast and cheap auto insurance coverage today with our quote comparison tool above.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#1 – Allstate: Top Overall Pick

Pros

• Excellent Customer Service: Allstate is known for its highly rated claims handling and customer service.
• Multiple Policy Discounts: Offers various discounts, especially for bundling with home insurance.
• User-Friendly Mobile App: Provides a convenient mobile app for easy policy management. Learn more about their premiums in our Allstate auto insurance review.

Cons

• Higher Costs: Allstate can be more expensive compared to some other insurers.
• Rate Increases: Rates may increase after an accident or claim.

#2 – Farmers: Best for Safety Discounts

Pros

• Personalized Customer Service: Farmers provides personalized service through a network of local agents.
• Wide Range of Discounts: Offers discounts for safe drivers, multi-policy, and other criteria. Check out this page Farmers auto insurance review to know more details about the discounts available.
• Additional Coverage Options: Provides options like rideshare insurance and extended coverage.

Cons

• Higher Rates: Rates with Farmers can be higher compared to some other major insurers.
• Limited Availability: Farmers may not be available in all states.

#3 – USAA: Best for Military Savings

Pros

• Outstanding Customer Service: USAA consistently receives high marks for customer service and claims satisfaction.
• Competitive Rates: As outlined in USAA auto insurance review, the offers competitive rates tailored for military members and their families.
• Extensive Coverage Options: Provides a wide range of coverage options and discounts.

Cons

• Limited Eligibility: Only available to military members, veterans, and their families.
• Limited Availability: USAA has limited availability in terms of who can become a member.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#4 – Progressive: Best for Loyalty Rewards

Pros

• Variety of Discounts: Progressive auto insurance review boasts various discounts, including safe driver and multi-policy discounts.
• Innovative Coverage Options: Provides innovative coverage options like Name Your Price® Tool and Snapshot®.
• Strong Online Presence: Offers robust online tools and a user-friendly website.

Cons

• Customer Service Concerns: Some customers report issues with customer service and claims handling.
• Rate Increases: Rates may increase significantly after an accident or claim.

#5 – State Farm: Best for Local Agents

Pros

• Extensive Network of Agents: State Farm has a large network of local agents offering personalized service.
• Wide Range of Discounts: Offers numerous discounts, including for safe driving and bundling policies. For discounts read our State Farm auto insurance discounts.
• Strong Financial Stability: State Farm has a solid financial strength rating.

Cons

• Higher Rates: State Farm tends to have higher rates compared to some other insurers.
• Limited Digital Experience: The online and mobile app experience may not be as robust as other insurers.

#6 – American Family: Best for Claims Service

Pros

• Bundle Discounts: Offers significant discounts for bundling auto and home insurance policies.
• Local Agent Network: Provides personalized service through a network of local agents. (Read more: American Family Auto Insurance Review).
• Innovative Coverage Options: Offers innovative options like KnowYourDrive® and accident forgiveness.

Cons

• Limited Availability: American Family may not be available in all states.
• Higher Rates: Premiums can be higher compared to some other insurers.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#7 – The Hartford: Best for Exclusive Benefits

Pros

• AARP Partnership: Offers auto insurance discounts through the AARP program.
• Enhanced Coverage Options: Provides benefits like RecoverCare and Lifetime Renewability®.
• Strong Financial Strength: The Hartford has a solid financial strength rating. Learn more in our The Hartford auto insurance review.

Cons

• Limited Availability: The Hartford may not be available in all states.
• Higher Rates: Premiums can be higher compared to some other insurers.

#8 – Nationwide: Best for Accident Forgiveness

Pros

• Wide Range of Coverage Options: Offers comprehensive coverage options for auto insurance.
• Multi-Policy Discounts: Provides discounts for bundling auto with home or renters insurance.
• Highly Rated Claims Service: Nationwide has good reviews for its claims service. For more information, read our Nationwide auto insurance review.

Cons

• Higher Rates: Nationwide premiums may be higher compared to competitors.
• Customer Service Concerns: Some customers have reported issues with customer service.

#9 – Amica Mutual: Best for Dividend Payments

Pros

• Top-Rated Customer Service: Amica consistently receives high marks for customer service and claims satisfaction.
• Dividend Policies: As mentioned in Amica auto insurance review, the company offers dividend policies that can reduce premiums.
• No Middleman: Directly manages claims and customer service.

Cons

• Limited Availability: Amica may not be available in all states.
• Higher Premiums: Premiums can be higher compared to some other insurers.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#10 – Liberty Mutual: Best for 24/7 Support

Pros

• Multi-Policy Discounts:  As mentioned in our Liberty Mutual auto insurance review, the company offers discounts for bundling auto with home or renters insurance.
• Wide Range of Coverage Options: Provides comprehensive coverage options.
• User-Friendly Digital Tools: Offers a robust website and mobile app for policy management.

Cons

• Higher Rates: Liberty Mutual premiums may be higher compared to competitors.
• Customer Service Concerns: Some customers have reported issues with customer service.

Companies With the Cheapest Auto Insurance in Colorado

The average Colorado driver pays about 10% more for auto insurance than in other states. Colorado’s high rates for car insurance comes from several factors, including heavy traffic in cities like Denver, high car theft rates in four major cities, and increased risk of accidents during winter weather. Read more in our Denver, CO auto insurance review.

Colorado Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by Coverage Level & Provider

You’ll need to compare quotes between companies to find the cheapest car insurance rates in Colorado for your unique situation.

The top auto insurance companies are a great place to start your search for affordable coverage. You can explore the companies offering the best rates for various demographics below, but you should still compare Colorado auto insurance quotes before signing up.

Minimum Auto Insurance Rates in Colorado

Most states require car insurance before registering your car or driving on a public street, and Colorado is one of them. The minimum auto insurance requirements by state may vary, but basic coverage is your cheapest option in Colorado, especially since state requirements are relatively low. You’ll need the following insurance before you can drive in Colorado:

• Bodily Injury Liability: $25,000 per person
• Bodily injury Liability: $50,000 per accident
• Property Damage Liability: $15,000 per accident

Coloradans don’t need other coverage types like personal injury protection (PIP) auto insurance or uninsured motorist insurance. However, insurance companies in Colorado must offer you uninsured motorist and medical payments coverage before you can sign a policy. Read more about Colorado minimum auto insurance requirements.

If you’re interested in finding the most affordable auto insurance quotes in Colorado, you can get an idea of what you might pay below:

Have you heard of Drivewise? It’s located in our Allstate app. We recently found out that customers who choose to use Drivewise are 25% less likely to have a severe collision than those who don’t. https://t.co/HNMxg3hVAZ

— Allstate (@Allstate) May 13, 2024

No matter which company you choose, you’ll pay less for minimum insurance than full coverage.

If you don’t want to buy car insurance in Colorado, you can self-insure. To do so, you can apply for a certificate of self-insurance from the state Insurance Commissioner, guaranteeing you can pay for damages you cause in an accident. However, this option costs more than paying for minimum insurance.

Full Coverage Auto Insurance Rates in Colorado

Colorado state law doesn’t require drivers to buy full coverage, but you’ll probably need it if you have a car lease or loan. Full coverage auto insurance refers to a suite of car insurance products protecting your car from the most common incidents that can damage it.

If you decide to buy full coverage in Colorado, your policy will include the following policies:

• Bodily Injury Liability: Bodily injury liability covers injuries you cause to other drivers, passengers, or pedestrians in an accident.
• Property Damage Liability: This liability insurance pays for damage you cause to cars, buildings, and other property types. It doesn’t cover your vehicle.
• Collision: You need collision auto insurance coverage if you want your insurance to cover your car in an accident. Collision insurance also covers you if you hit a stationary object.
• Comprehensive: There’s a lot more than collisions that can damage your car. Comprehensive auto insurance covers your vehicle from extreme weather, fire, vandalism, theft, and animal contact.
• Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist: Colorado requires drivers to carry insurance, but not everyone follows the law. Uninsured motorist coverage helps cover your damage caused by another driver with no insurance, insufficient insurance, or a hit-and-run driver.
• Medical Payments: Medical payments insurance pays for medical expenses after you or your passengers get injured in an accident, no matter who was at fault.

While full coverage offers excellent protection for your car, it costs more than minimum insurance. There are various factors that affect auto insurance rates, but you can get an idea of how much you might pay for full coverage below.

For full coverage, State Farm and Nationwide have the cheapest average rates. The third cheapest option — Geico — is nearly $40 a month more expensive, despite being one of the most affordable options for minimum insurance.

Read our State Farm auto insurance review to find out more.

Colorado Auto Insurance Rates by Age and Gender

As mentioned, car insurance companies consider several factors to craft your rates. Two of the most influential elements of your rates are your age and gender. Average auto insurance rates by age may differ depending on the insurance company.

Young people pay more for insurance because they’re statistically more likely to engage in reckless behaviors, drive distracted, and cause accidents. They also lack the experience to handle dangerous situations on the road.

Similarly, men are more likely than women to engage in dangerous driving behaviors, like not wearing a seat belt or driving under the influence.

For these reasons, young drivers and men pay more for insurance. However, there’s some good news — your rates will lower around age 25 if you keep your driving record clean. The price gap between genders also lessens with age.

Colorado teens pay about 10% more for insurance than the national average for young drivers and three times more than older Coloradans. Nationwide often has the cheapest rates for young drivers, but you should always look at multiple companies before signing up for a policy — you might find better prices elsewhere.

Learn More: Cheapest Teen Driver Auto Insurance in Colorado

Colorado Auto Insurance Rates by Credit Score

Most states allow companies to use credit scores to determine insurance rates, and Colorado is one of them. Auto insurance and your credit score can affect each other in a couple of key ways.

The first way is that companies assume people with higher scores are more likely to pay their monthly bills on time. Secondly, people with lower scores are statistically more likely to get into accidents.

Colorado Full Coverage Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by Credit Score & Provider

Once again, Nationwide has the cheapest average for insurance in Colorado if you have a low credit score. Geico and State Farm also offer lower rates but cost significantly more than Nationwide.

If you have a low credit score, you don’t need to be stuck with high rates forever. If you increase your credit score, your insurance rates will drop.

Colorado Auto Insurance Rates After an Accident

While many factors go into your insurance quote, they all work together to predict your riskiness. Insurance companies charge more for people they think will file a claim in the future, and your driving record is one of the most telling factors for your risk.

Accidents on your driving record can increase your rates by up to 42%, and if you have too many, you’ll need to find high-risk auto insurance. However, some companies are a little more lenient than others — check average Coloradan rates after an accident below.

Colorado Full Coverage Auto Insurance Monthly Rates & Provider: Clean Record vs. One Accident

Although Nationwide is usually the most affordable company, State Farm offers the lowest rates after an at-fault accident. Nationwide is $41 more expensive, and Farmers comes in third place, costing over $100 more.

Rates after an at-fault accident are always more expensive, but they won’t stay high forever. If you can keep your driving record clean of additional accidents and other incidents, your rates will return to normal in about three years.

Colorado Auto Insurance by City

From little ski towns like Breckenridge to the largest city in the state, Denver, Coloradans have various beautiful choices. Of course, living in a big city usually comes with higher rates, but you can check which towns have the lowest rates below.

As you might expect, car insurance rates in Denver, Colorado Springs, and Aurora are some of the highest in the state. These cities are some of the most densely populated in Colorado, resulting in more traffic, higher car theft rates, and accidents. Also, auto insurance rates by ZIP code may differ.

Colorado Auto Insurance Rates After a DUI

Of all the things you can do to increase your car insurance rates, getting a DUI is one of the worst. DUIs can increase your rates by up to 74% and carry legal fees, license suspension, and jail time. Is cheap auto insurance with a DUI possible?

Like at-fault accidents, some companies are more forgiving than others after a DUI. However, remember that some companies refuse to work with drivers after even one DUI — you’ll need high-risk insurance if you can’t find standard insurance.

Check below to see how much insurance costs after a DUI for the average driver in Colorado.

Colorado Full Coverage Auto Insurance Monthly Rates & Provider: Clean Record vs. One DUI

State Farm has the lowest rates for Colorado drivers after a DUI, with Progressive taking a distant second place. While Nationwide is usually one of the cheapest options in Colorado, it’s nearly $70 more expensive than Progressive.

Therefore, it’s important to compare rates after you get a DUI, even if you already have insurance. However, you don’t need to pay high prices forever. If you avoid adding incidents to your record, a DUI stops affecting your rates after seven years.

Cost of Auto Insurance in Your City: Compare Rates Across Colorado Locations

Delve into the cost of auto insurance across different cities in Colorado, including Colorado Springs, Lakewood, Denver, Littleton, Fort Collins, Wheat Ridge, and Keenesburg. Start comparing rates now to find the best insurance options for you.

Colorado Auto Insurance Cost by City

Colorado’s Auto Insurance Laws

You already know how much insurance you need to drive or register your car in Colorado, but you should learn about other coverage laws in the Centennial State.

Coloradans must show proof of insurance upon request from any law enforcement.

If you’re driving without insurance, you’ll face heavy consequences, like:

• Four points on your license
• $500 fine
• License suspension until you submit proof of insurance to the DMV

Driving without auto insurance comes with harsh consequences. You’ll face harsher consequences beyond your first offense. For example, you’ll have a $1,000 fine and a four-month mandatory license suspension for your second offense. Additional offenses come with a $1,000 fine and a license suspension of up to eight months.

Courts might also order 40 hours of community service for any charge of driving without insurance. After your second offense of driving without Colorado auto insurance, you’ll face up to a year in jail. You’ll also need to file SR-22 auto insurance for three years after driving without insurance.

Unlike many other states, Colorado requires a minimum amount of insurance for various alternative vehicles. For example, scooter drivers need a valid license to meet the state’s minimum scooter insurance requirements.

Colorado’s DUI Laws

Colorado splits its DUIs into three categories based on the level of intoxication.

The three categories are:

• DUI: Driving while under the influence of drugs or alcohol qualifies as a DUI, no matter how intoxicated you are.
• DWAI: A DWAI — or driving while ability impaired — is reserved for drivers with a blood alcohol content level between 0.05% and 0.08%.
• DUI Per Se: DUI per se means you drove with a blood alcohol content of 0.08% or higher.

DUI laws in Colorado are complicated, but you can get an idea of what penalties you might face below:

• DUI/DUI Per Se First Offense: Up to 365 days in jail, a $1,000 fine, an ignition interlock device (IID) installed in your car for eight months, a nine-month license suspension, and 96 hours of community service.
• DUI/DUI Per Se Second Offense: Up to 365 days in jail, a $1,500 fine, an IID for five years, an indefinite period for license suspension, and 120 hours of community service.
• DUI/DUI Per Se Third Offense: Up to 365 days in jail, a $1,500 fine, an IID for five years, a one-year license suspension, and 120 hours of community service.
• DWAI: Up to 180 days in jail, a $500 fine, and 48 hours of community service.

You’ll also need to complete an alcohol or drug evaluation and any educational programs the state recommends. All fees associated with alcohol educational courses fall on the driver.

As for probation, you’ll face at least two years after your second DUI offense.

Optional Auto Insurance Options you can Buy in Colorado

While liability insurance is a requirement in Colorado, buying more coverage for your vehicle is never a bad idea. Insurance companies offer add-ons to increase your policy’s value and car protection.

If you total a car 🚘worth $13,000 but you owe $15,000, you'll have to make up the $2,000💰 difference and pay your lender back for a totaled car. GAP insurance can fix that. https://t.co/27f1xf1ARb has done the research and is ready to help. Check out👉: https://t.co/5bIvPhZZxo pic.twitter.com/fAl2YwjN9n

— AutoInsurance.org (@AutoInsurance) September 26, 2023

Popular add-ons in Colorado include:

• Roadside Assistance: Roadside assistance comes to the rescue when you get stranded on the side of the road. Most plans include towing, battery jumps, tire changes, fuel delivery, and locksmith services.
• Accident Forgiveness: If you buy accident forgiveness, your insurance company forgets your first accident. Most companies require drivers to be accident-free for some time before qualifying.
• Rental Car Reimbursement: This add-on covers you if you need a rental car while your vehicle gets repaired after a covered accident.
• Insurance for Customized Cars: A standard policy only covers the parts your car comes with. If you customize your vehicle, you’ll need custom parts and equipment insurance to cover it.
• Gap insurance: Gap insurance covers the difference between the remainder of your car loan and your car’s actual cash value if your car gets totaled.

Although add-ons increase your policy coverage, you should be mindful of what you buy. Extra coverage can significantly increase how much you’ll pay for insurance.

Colorado SR-22 Auto Insurance

While you’ll often hear it referred to as insurance, SR-22s are not a form of coverage. Instead, SR-22s are a form the Colorado DMV requires drivers to file after certain driving incidents. An SR-22 form proves you’ve purchased enough coverage to meet Colorado’s minimum insurance requirements.

You’ll probably need to submit SR-22 auto insurance after the following incidents:

• DUI/DWAI/DUI per se charge
• Driving with a suspended license
• Driving without insurance
• Multiple traffic tickets in a short period

Though every situation is different, most drivers must submit continuous SR-22 insurance for three years. However, the DMV won’t accept your form if you file it yourself. Instead, you’ll need an insurance company to file for you.

How to get Colorado SR-22 Auto Insurance

While it’s not fun to need SR-22 insurance, getting it in Colorado isn’t usually a challenge. SR-22 insurance costs more than a standard policy, and some companies might reject applicants they consider too high-risk, but it’s generally easy to find.

When you need SR-22 insurance, it’s important to research your options, even if you already have a policy. People with insurance policies have the easiest option to get SR-22 coverage since most companies are willing to file for you. If you already have insurance, you should still compare rates with other companies to ensure you get the best price.

To add SR-22 coverage to an existing policy, call a representative and tell them what you need. Most companies charge a filing fee of about $25 a month, but it will keep you driving.

Applying for SR-22 insurance works the same for people without a current policy as for standard coverage. Let the company know you need it to file SR-22 forms on your behalf. Some companies will reject your application, but most provide coverage without a problem.

Considering getting Progressive or The General car insurance in Colorado if you’re having trouble getting SR-22 auto insurance. Both companies offer high-risk coverage to those who need SR-22 coverage.

Read More:

• Progressive Auto Insurance Review
• Progressive SR-22 Insurance Review
• The General Auto Insurance Review

When you need SR-22 insurance, Colorado will likely suspend your license until you submit proof. That’s easy enough when you have a car, but how do you buy insurance if you don’t own a vehicle?

An easy solution if you find yourself in this situation is a non-owner auto insurance policy. Unlike standard car insurance following the vehicle, non-owner insurance follows you, meaning you’re covered no matter what car you drive. It also allows you to purchase the state minimum requirements in Colorado to get your license reinstated.

How to Save on Colorado Auto Insurance Coverage

Finding affordable car insurance in Colorado is crucial, as drivers here pay about 10% more than the national average. To keep costs down, consider these tips. First, look for discounts offered by insurance companies, such as those for good students, safe drivers, or bundling policies. Second, you can lower your coverage amounts to fit your budget, although this may mean less protection for your car.

Third, maintaining a clean driving record is essential since incidents can drastically raise your rates. Fourth, consider raising your deductible, which will lower your monthly premiums. Another option is usage-based insurance, where your driving behavior affects your rates. Finally, comparing quotes from different companies is vital; signing up for the first policy you see could mean overpaying.

While comparing auto insurance discounts and choosing the right coverage level is important, comparing quotes is the most vital step to finding affordable insurance.

Find Cheap Colorado Auto Insurance Rates Today

Colorado auto insurance costs about 10% more than the national average, so finding cheap car insurance in Colorado might be more difficult. However, you’ll find affordable coverage in Colorado from companies such as Liberty Mutual, Geico, and State Farm auto insurance.

While these companies have the lowest average rates for various demographics, your Colorad auto insurance quote will consider your situation. Compare rates with as many companies as possible before you sign up to find the best price.

If you’re looking to lower your auto insurance premiums, enter your ZIP code into our free quote comparison tool below to compare your rates against the top insurers.