Best Pay-As-You-Go Auto Insurance in Colorado (Our Top 10 Picks for 2026)

Root, Metromile, and Nationwide have the best pay-as-you-go auto insurance in Colorado.

Root is our top pick for pay-per-mile auto insurance in Colorado. It may not have the cheapest rates, but its focus on insuring only the best drivers guarantees your rates won’t increase because other drivers are filing too many Colorado auto insurance claims.

Our Top 10 Company Picks: Best Pay-As-You-Go Auto Insurance in Colorado

Explore our Colorado pay-per-mile auto insurance guide below to discover which company has the perfect coverage options for your needs. Then, enter your ZIP code into our free comparison tool above to start comparing rates.

#1 – Root: Top Pick Overall

Pros

• Low Rates: Root offers the best pay-per-mile car insurance in Colorado in part because it has affordable rates. Root doesn’t insure bad drivers, which helps keep rates low.
• Customized Quotes: The amount you pay at Root is determined by how you drive. Good drivers are rewarded at Root with the cheapest pay-per-mile car insurance rates.
• User-Friendly App: Track your driving habits and manage your policy with Root’s highly-rated mobile app. See what customers say about the app in our Root auto insurance review.

Cons

• Strict Eligibility Requirements: Root only insures drivers who regularly practice safe driving. If you don’t pass the Root test, your application will be denied.
• Traditional Support Lacking: Root focuses on a more digital approach to insurance, so finding help from a representative can be difficult.

#2 – Metromile: Best Pay-Per-Mile Quotes

Pros

• Transparent Pricing: Metromile makes it easy to understand what you’ll be paying for your insurance with its transparent pricing.
• True Pay-As-You-Go Insurance: As one of the only companies that only offers pay-per-mile insurance policies, Metromile specializes in pay-as-you-go coverage.
• User-Friendly App: Manage your Metromile policy with ease on the user-friendly mobile app.

Cons

• More Complaints Than Expected: With almost four times as many complaints as the national average, Metromile does not have the best track record with its customers.
• Limited Coverage Options: Metromile doesn’t offer as many add-ons as some of its competitors. Explore your Metromile full coverage options in our Metromile auto insurance review.

#3 – Nationwide: Best for Vanishing Deductible

Pros

• Vanishing Deductible: Nationwide offers a variety of add-ons, including its vanishing deductible which can cover up to $500 of your deductible. Learn how it works in our Nationwide insurance review.
• UBI Programs: Nationwide has two usage-based insurance (UBI) programs. SmartRide offers up to 40% off your insurance for safe driving, while SmartMiles is a pay-per-mile option.
• Low Rates for Teens: Young drivers can struggle to find affordable Colorado auto insurance rates, but Nationwide offers cheap quotes for teens.

Cons

• Lacking Coverage Options: Despite being one of the biggest Colorado auto insurance companies, Nationwide doesn’t have the longest list of add-ons.
• Higher Rates: High-risk drivers with speeding tickets, at-fault accidents, or DUIs will likely find cheaper rates elsewhere.

#4 – Farmers: Best List of Auto Insurance Discounts

Pros

• Signal App: Farmers doesn’t offer a true pay-per-mile option, but you can still earn savings for your low-mileage driving with the Signal app. See how in our Farmers auto insurance review.
• Ample Discounts: Farmers offers an impressive 23 discounts for drivers to take advantage of and find the cheapest auto insurance in Colorado.
• Coverage Options: Get the most out of your Nationwide policy by adding things like customized equipment coverage and roadside assistance.

Cons

• Higher Premiums: Farmers is an affordable option when you sign up for Signal, but premiums can be expensive if you don’t participate.
• Rate Increases With Signal: If you don’t drive well enough, Signal is one of the few UBI programs that will increase your rates.

#5 – Allstate: Best for Full Coverage Service

Pros

• Coverage Options: You’ll find plenty of add-on options to customize your policy with at Allstate. See all your add-on options in our Allstate auto insurance review.
• Milewise: Allstate offers two UBI programs, and Milewise is its pay-per-mile option. If you prefer a discount for your driving instead, consider Drivewise.
• Daily Mileage Cap: You won’t have to worry about your rates skyrocketing if you take a road trip – Allstate caps the mileage you can be charged for in a single day at 250 miles.

Cons

• Mixed Reviews: Allstate may be one of the largest insurance companies in the country, but it doesn’t always leave customers happy.
• Expensive Premiums: Colorado pay-per-mile insurance reviews say Allstate is an affordable low-mileage driver, but it usually has higher rates for everyone else.

#6 – Liberty Mutual: Best for Diverse Coverage Opportunities

Pros

• Unique Coverage Options: Customize your Liberty Mutual policy to get the exact coverage you want with plenty of add-ons to choose from.
• RightTrack: You can save money on auto insurance as a low-mileage driver by enrolling in RightTrack, which offers a maximum discount of 30%. Read more in our Liberty Mutual RightTrack review.
• Specialty Discounts: Get the best auto insurance in Colorado with 17 discounts. Teachers and other educators can get an exclusive discount from Liberty Mutual.

Cons

• More Complaints Than Expected: Liberty Mutual receives a higher number of complaints, which is unfortunate considering Colorado auto insurance claims laws.
• Discontinued ByMile: While it once offered a pay-per-mile insurance option, Liberty Mutual canceled its ByMile program to start RightTrack.

#7 – Progressive: Best for Innovative Digital Tools

Pros

• Digital Tools: Progressive offers a variety of digital tools to help drivers looking for a more modern insurance experience. Explore these tools in our Progressive auto insurance review.
• Snapshot: Save up to 30% by enrolling in Progressive’s UBI program Snapshot and consistently practicing safe driving habits.
• Automatic Discounts: Progressive offers 13 discounts, many of which automatically apply to your account once you qualify.

Cons

• Rate Hikes: Many customers report that their Progressive car insurance in Colorado unexpectedly increased, even when nothing had changed about their policy.
• Low Loyalty: Despite efforts to improve, Progressive still struggles with its customer loyalty ratings.

#8 – Geico: Best for Affordable Car Insurance Rates

Pros

• Low Rates: Get affordable coverage from Geico, no matter what type of driver you are. Geico car insurance in Colorado is typically one of the cheapest car insurance options for all drivers.
• DriveEasy: Save up to 25% on your insurance by enrolling in Geico’s UBI program, DriveEasy.
• Fewer Complaints: Geico receives fewer customer complaints than many insurance companies of similar size. See how Geico keeps its customers happy in our Geico auto insurance review.

Cons

• Fewer Coverage Options: Geico has a surprising lack of coverage options, including popular add-ons like gap insurance.
• Higher Rates for Some: One of the only groups of people Geico does not offer cheap rates to are drivers with DUIs.

#9 – State Farm: Best for Personalized Service

Pros

• Solid Discounts: Keep your insurance rates low with State Farm’s selection of 13 discounts. See how many you might qualify for in our State Farm auto insurance review.
• Drive Safe & Save: You can’t get pay-per-mile State Farm car insurance in Colorado, but Drive Safe & Save is the next best thing. Safe drivers can save up to 30% by enrolling in the UBI program.
• Extensive Network of Agents: State Farm agents are in every corner of Colorado, so getting personalized service is usually a breeze.

Cons

• Limited Coverage Options: State Farm has great rates and a solid UBI program, but it lacks many of the coverage options you can find at other companies.
• Availability Varies: State Farm’s UBI program and discounts vary by ZIP code. Speak with a representative to see what’s available in your area.

#10 – USAA: Best for Active or Retired Military Members

Pros

• SafePilot: Low-mileage drivers should consider taking advantage of USAA’s UBI program, SafePilot, which offers a maximum savings of up to 30%.
• Low Rates: No matter what type of driver you are or where you live, USAA is almost always the cheapest auto insurance option in Colorado.
• Superb Customer Service: USAA representatives have a reputation for being professional, friendly, and helpful.

Cons

• No Gap Insurance: USAA offers auto loan services and car insurance, but it doesn’t sell gap insurance. Learn more about the services USAA does offer in our review of USAA auto insurance.
• Eligibility Requirements: You need to be a USAA member to buy auto insurance. Only active or retired military members and their direct families can become USAA members.

Learn How Colorado Pay-As-You-Go Auto Insurance Works

Standard policies and pay-as-you-go auto insurance plans work in almost the same way. The one exception is how your rates are calculated.

Pay-per-mile companies determine how much you’ll pay in two parts. The first is your monthly base fee, which is what you’ll pay even if you don’t drive at all. Then, the company will determine your fee per mile, which is usually a few cents.

The best pay-as-you-go auto insurance companies offer a great way to find affordable insurance for infrequent drivers. However, not everyone will benefit from these plans. If you put more than 10,000 miles on your car every year, a standard policy is probably a better option.

Why Colorado Auto Insurance Rates Keep Going Up

While many things influence car insurance prices — including the top seven factors that affect auto insurance rates — it seems like everyone is paying more for coverage these days.

Before we delve into why rates are high, take a look below to see how much the average driver pays in your state.

Colorado Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by Age, Gender, & Coverage Level

Insurance rates have been increasing for a variety of reasons. In Colorado, some of the primary culprits are denser traffic, more claims, and a larger population of drivers on the road.

While rates are high, however, it doesn’t mean you can’t find affordable prices. One way to save on your insurance is to compare rates with multiple companies. Check below to see how much our top pay-as-you-go companies charge on average.

Pay-As-You-Go Auto Insurance in Colorado: Monthly Rates by Coverage Level & Provider

Rates also vary based on where you live. Compare the rates below to see what the average driver pays for insurance in some of Colorado’s largest cities.

Colorado Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by Age, Gender, & City

As you can see, rates can be high for some drivers in Colorado. However, there are additional steps you can take to get lower rates, especially when you’re a low-mileage driver.

How Pay-As-You-Go Lowers Colorado Auto Insurance Rates

Pay-as-you-go insurance can help you save significantly as long as you’re a low-mileage driver. Low-mileage drivers can see their rates reduced by half or more by switching to a pay-per-mile plan.

pic.twitter.com/LUSkSDu646

— Metromile (@Metromile) July 22, 2022

Check the rates below to get an idea of how annual mileage affects your auto insurance rates.

Colorado Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by Age, Gender, & Annual Mileage

Low-mileage drivers can benefit greatly from signing up for a pay-per-mile auto insurance policy. Most pay-per-mile companies offer a Colorado pay-as-you-drive insurance calculator to help you determine how much you might pay for coverage.

Ways to Get Cheaper Colorado Auto Insurance Quotes

Aside from signing up for pay-per-mile insurance, there are plenty of ways to lower your quotes.

Consider the discounts from our top companies below.

Besides getting a low-mileage auto insurance discount, there are other ways to save. Consider the following methods to save:

• Choose a higher deductible
• Lower your coverage
• Keep your driving record clean
• Improve your credit score

Of course, one of the most important ways to find low rates is to compare quotes. Most major insurance companies offer free quote request forms on their websites.

If you want to save time, use a quote comparison tool to look at multiple rates at once. Choosing this method will help you find affordable coverage quickly.

Get The Best Pay-As-You-Go Auto Insurance in Colorado

Whether you want the bare minimum amount of insurance or a full coverage policy with collision and comprehensive auto insurance, pay-as-you-go auto insurance can help low-mileage drivers save.

Now that you know which companies offer the best pay-as-you-go auto insurance, your next step should be comparing rates. Enter your ZIP code into our free comparison tool below to get started.